FIRST District System

I've noticed on Chief Delphi recently that a lot of people have been posting FiM style rankings for their respective regions and it got me thinking (not always a good thing) what would FRC look like if all of the United States went to districts.

But, first a little background on the District System for those that don't know or have been living under a rock since 2009. The district system was created in the summer of 2008 in Michigan as a way to decrease cost and increase the value and sustainability of the FIRST Robotics Competition. It was piloted in 2009 in Michigan and has been used every since. The difference between the standard regional model and the district system is that rather than pay $5000 for one Regional event you get to play at two District event. District events are around the size of a small Regional, normally 40 teams, and takes place on Friday and Saturday only. The absences of practice day and team access to the robot is something for another post. In 2011 Eastern Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware formed the Mid-Atlantic Region. More info about the district system can be found here.

My District system would allow every team two districts event for the initial registration price. Since everyone will be on districts, team can go and play anywhere. They will be required to have one event in their home region but the second and so on can be where they want. Teams that go to more than two districts will pay the third district fee from the region where the third district is and have the option before Kickoff to pick which two district they want to count for point and which one will just be for practice. If they don't pick their first two district event will be point events.

Before I lay out what states are in each Region a little note about Championship spots for each Region. The number of spots are based off of a 600 team, 8 division Championship that I wrote about last year. They would be divided up as shown below:

Championship Berths

600 Total

20 for Hall of Fame Team

3 for Previous year's Winners

1 for Previous year's EI

1 for Previous year's RAS

30 for 5 Canadian Regionals

6 for Israeli Regional

6 for Australian Regional

6 for Mexican Regional

7 for International Team spots

520 for USA Regions

I know this will be controversial but I have limited spots for Hall of Fame teams to 20. That means that after you win Championship Chairman's you would get a 20 year exemption to Championship starting the next year. Teams that won more than 20 years ago would still be in the Hall of Fame, they would be just to qualify the old fashion way.

The seven spots for International teams are open to teams who do not have a regional in their country. They can either go to another foreign regional or come and play in the US. If they do the latter they will get two districts like everyone else, but will not be obligated to play at a region championship. Rather they will be ranked along with all of the other International teams and the top 7 will earn berth at Champs.

And now onto the district split:

FRC Districts
Name of Region	States	Number of Teams	Number of District Event	World Championship Berths
New England FIRST	CT, MA, VT, ME, NH, RI, Eastern NY	164	9	37
FIRST New York	Southern NY	99	5	22
Mid-Atlantic Region	DE, NJ, Eastern PA	109	6	24
FIRST Capital Region	MD, DC, VA	123	7	28
Carolina FIRST	SC, NC	78	4	17
FIRST South	GA, Eastern TN, AL, FL Panhandle	91	5	20
Florida FIRST	FL Peninsula	72	4	16
Ohio Valley Region	OH, Western PA, Western NY, WV, KY	143	8	32
Midwest Region	IL, IN, WI	147	8	33
FIRST in Michigan	MI	211	11	47
FIRST in Minnesota	MN, SD, ND	187	10	42
Mississippi River Region	LA, MS, Western TN, AR	72	4	16
Gateway Region	MO, KS, OK, IA, NE	135	7	30
Texas FIRST	TX	142	8	32
FIRST Northwest	WA, OR, ID, AK, MT	179	9	40
Rocky Mountain FIRST	UT, CO, WY	64	4	14
FIRST Southwest	NV, AZ, NM	61	4	14
NOCAL FIRST	Northern CA	105	9	24
SOCAL FIRST	Southern CA, HI	141	8	32

A couple of notes on the setup:

• New York gets split between New England, Ohio Valley, and New York City. NYC could join MAR and double the size of that region.
• The Dakotas got added to Minnesota because there are only like 5 teams between the two states.
• Rocky Mountain and the Southwest could easily be combined, but I left then separate because a combined region may be too large.
• Hawaii goes with SOCAL because it doesn't have enough teams for its own region. They would probably have a district event or two on Hawaii and then teams would go to California for Champs.
• 3 regions, FiM, FiMn, and NW all qualify over 40 teams for Championships which means that teams could qualify that don't make elims at the Region Championship. A way to fix this would be to have two simultaneous Region Championships like NE wants to do. This could all fix the UP problem in Michigan if one of the events was farther north.

That's about it, I'm not saying I'm right but here's my idea. Tell me what you think.

2013 Orlando Regional Thoughts

I meant to get this out sooner but coming back up to NC State after Spring Break I had a paper due yesterday and a test today, so hopefully you can forgive me (By you I mean my mom cause I'm pretty sure she is the only person that reads my blog).

All this post will include are a couple thoughts on Ultimate Ascent through two weeks and some fun facts from the Orlando Regional this past weekend.

Thoughts:

• Field Reset is a pain in the ass!!!! I can only imagine how much worse it would be if human players could throw white Frisbees.
• The game moves relatively fast and a good robot can get 3-4 scoring runs in during teleop and still hang.
• With 45 Frisbees in the drivers stations there is no need to be able to pick up off the ground at this point in the season.
• Most human player throws were towards the main goals and not towards the pyramid goal where the colored Frisbees are actually special.

Fun Facts:

• 79 became the 9th team to win multiple Florida/Orlando Regionals joining 233, 1251, 86, 179, 180, 1649, 108, and 1592 (If I forgot anyone I am sorry).
• 744 won their first Regional as a team and as a school in 13 years of FRC.
• 1772 was the first out-of-state team to win the Florida Regional since 2007 (Only the 4th such team since 2002) and that team, 1270, went on to qualify for Einstein. 
• 79 eliminated 233 at the Orlando Regional for the first time ever. On the other hand 233 has eliminated 79 at least three times (all while I was a student!)
• 4451 was the first rookie to make finals at the Orlando Regional since 1902 in 2006
• 744 made their 3rd finals appearance in 5 years, 79 their 5th in 11 years and 233 their 3rd consecutive and 8th overall since 2002.
• All three members of the winning alliance were ranked lower than 10th.
• 79 and 744 partnered up for the 2nd time since 2009 with 744 being the alliance captain both times.
• 79 qualified for Championship for the 16th year in a row, which should be the longest active non-Hall of Fame streak. Surprisingly the only time Krunch didn't merit qualify was 2008.

That about wraps up this post and if I think of anything else I will go back and add it later.

Firefly Analysis

A while back watching The Big Bang Theory they referenced Firefly and I decided to give it a shot and see if I liked it. Fast forward three month and this week I wrapped up watching not only the TV show but Serenity as well. I have a couple of thoughts on why it was cancelled and then I'll go into my thoughts of the series.

As for the reason that Firefly was cancelled I can think of three reasons.
1) I learned from The Big Bang Theory that Firefly was broadcasts on Friday nights and my first reaction was no wonder the show had low rating. Friday is not a good night for TV unless your a movie or a sport.
2) The show is a space western and I think that Joss Whedon took the western part a little to literally. Initially it was just a little to western for me, but by the end of the series it adjusted to more spacey.
3) Fox. I don't need to say much more but from broadcasting it on Friday nights to making Joss Whedon film a new pilot to airing episodes out of order, Fox is really to blame for Firefly's failure.

Now to my thoughts of the show:
Overall I loved it. During the final scenes of Serenity I was legitimately upset that the show was ending, and I don't normally fell that way about TV. I came to really like the characters and the thought of Inara leaving really worried me until I remembered that there was only one episode left. I don't really know what else it say. I found Firefly funny, entertaining and there really wasn't any cast member that I didn't like.

If you haven't ever seem Firefly and Serenity I would highly recommend it and if Joss Whedon is out there if you're not going to revive the show can you at least publish some books about what happens to everyone after they leave Mr. Universe's moon.

Thanks,
New Firefly fanboy Jacob